Shepherdology, Part 3
This sermon examines the biblical terminology for church leadership, demonstrating that the Greek terms for elder, overseer, and pastor all refer to the same permanent office of spiritual leadership. By analyzing passages such as Acts 20 and 1 Peter 5, the teaching argues that these titles are interchangeable and describe a plurality of leaders who share equal authority and responsibility. The message critiques the modern use of hierarchical titles like ‘senior pastor’ or ‘CEO,’ which create unbiblical distinctions among leaders. Instead, the congregation is encouraged to view all elders as equal shepherds of the flock, emphasizing a model of shared oversight and mutual submission rather than a corporate-style hierarchy.
Transcript
So when we talk about leadership, it’s not leadership in the community. It’s not leadership in the saints’ homes. It’s spiritual leadership over… We don’t get caught up in either worldly titles. From time to time, I’ll hear somebody talk about the CEO of their church. We don’t dabble in any of that, and it’s important to… focus on the terminology that scripture uses. Can I go down on the volume just a little bit for whoever? And it’s leadership, not lordship.
And so I hope that you saw and sensed some of that last week as we just had a family discussion. I was sharing with one brother this week that had I come and just said, look, this is what we’re doing. I mean, People would bristle and probably leave, but we wanna lead the saints along and hopefully they follow and when they hesitate, we wanna come alongside them and update, answer questions. The second line there, a multiple number of godly men and so it talks not only about character, but the plurality and that’s what we’ve been praying for. Great applications in the sermon today, just very, I mean, God doesn’t need, well, you said it well. We need a plurality because God is the one that mapped it out. And so we come to the focus of today’s lesson.
This office is referred to in Scripture as Three different terms, elders, overseers, and pastors or shepherds, and I’ll try and talk about each of those. Under what government have some of you dear people, how have you functioned? Under what government have you functioned in times past? And I’m talking about the structure. Maybe what were the titles?
Senior pastor is a very common one. We’ll come back to that. Yes, Stuart. Okay, congregational, where everybody votes on everything. How many Southern Baptists history? Yeah, a lot of Southern Baptists where they vote on everything. What else? Anybody been in a church government that was… Pastor and deacons, very common. Almost elders have been brushed aside, and so we’re going to mop up on all of that one.
So there’s three Greek words that are used with reference to the primary permanent office of spiritual leadership in the church. Why would I call it primary? The primary office of spiritual leadership. Teaching is important, absolutely. Is there more than one office of leadership in the church by God’s design? Somebody bail me out here, I’m just… What is it? Deacon, right? So the primary office is that of eldership, but when I say permanent, what do we mean by permanent?
Are we gonna have elders in heaven? No. What we’re talking about here is just what God has designed for the church from the beginning to the end of the church here in our day. So let’s go to the terminology. And the first one is the word from which we, or to which we translate as elder. It’s presbyteros. What did you hear there? Presbyterian. Presbyterian.
And the interesting thing is in the 30 or 40 years that I’ve served, it’s become more and more the case that we are more Presbyterian than a lot of Presbyterian churches because that word communicates a plurality of elders all on the same level and yet in a lot of Presbyterian churches, even solid ones like PCA, They will have a senior pastor that is set apart and above the other elders.
They call them ruling elders or whatever. And so you have this inbuilt distinction, and Scripture doesn’t know anything of it. So the word is used about 70 times in the New Testament, and typically it’s used with reference to age. Now, does that mean that elder… An elder has to be an old man. There were chuckles, but no, it does not indicate that. In fact, there are several places where Paul specifically tells a younger man, Titus and Timothy, that that is absolutely not a prerequisite.
Historically, the term… not only the term, but the importance of the office of elder just kind of fell by the wayside. And we built up other titles, not the least of which is pastor, but bishop came and overseer, which is separate and distinct from the elder office in some churches. And so it We want to pause and we want to look at the terminology and the way that it’s used. But presbyteros in its simplest form just refers to mature age. There’s a non-technical use of this word, aged or older, and it implies seniority.
It actually does. And so John chapter 8 verse 9 says, When they heard it, they began going out one by one, beginning with the older ones. And he was left alone and the woman where she was in the center of the court. And so it clearly refers to older saints. And I think that’s exactly the way the apostle John uses this word in his second epistle.
Just listen to this. The elder to the chosen lady and her children. And so he’s talking about himself. which is always a safe way to go, rather than me designating any of you as elderly. When you identify yourself as such, that’s much safer. In the third epistle of John, he does the same thing, the elder to the beloved Gaius. He’s talking about himself again. He’s acknowledging his seniority, his age, So that’s the non-technical use, just referring to older people.
And then there’s a technical use of the word referring to the office of the Jewish system of elder, and it’s used 28 times in that way throughout the New Testament. Just one example, Matthew 16, 21. From that time, Jesus began to show his disciples that he must go to Jerusalem, suffer many things from the elders. And so they had an office of presbyteros in the Jewish religious system. And there’s a third way that the word is used, not only, rather a second way, the second technical way that it’s used, not only the Jewish system of elders, but eternal elders. And these are the ones, the heavenly council, if you want to call them that, the 24 who surround God’s throne, 13 times just in the book of Revelations alone.
Again, just one example, Revelation 4.4, around the throne were 24 thrones, and upon the thrones I saw 24 elders sitting clothed in white garments and and golden crowns on their heads. And so that’s referring to these individuals who are functioning in some capacity of leadership there, not the least of which is directing and guiding the worship. So the third use is the Christian church elder.
Different entirely than, largely, than the Jewish system elder, and this is everywhere in the New Testament, Acts 1.30. The office is just mentioned. This they did, sending this gift in charge of Barnabas and Saul to the elders. And so just as a mention that there was some office there in the church referred to as the elders.
In Acts 14.23, it’s much more formally set forth, if you will, established.
Acts 14.23 says, when they had appointed elders for them in every church, and now you have a solidifying of this leadership that at least involves the office of elder.
Acts 15, multiple places in Acts 15 says, And then Acts 16.4, just one example again. The apostles and the elders came together to look into this matter. And so now you have kind of a melding of the apostles, whose leadership is temporary in the new fledgling church, and the elders, which are going to pick up and take on the leadership of the church as the apostles do. die or are martyred. There’s a beautiful example of elders really functioning in Acts chapter 20, where the Ephesian elders are summoned to come and meet with Paul. And it just says, from Miletus he sent to Ephesus and called to him the elders of the church. He didn’t call anyone else. He didn’t call a bishop. He didn’t call the deacons. He called the leaders of the church, and they were titled elders.
Timothy, Paul writing to Timothy, he mentions what is translated there as the presbytery. Interestingly enough, do not neglect the spiritual gift within you, he admonishes Timothy, which is bestowed on you through the prophetic utterance with the laying on of hands of by the presbytery, that is the elders of the church. And so it just speaks of the body of leadership, the body of elders, as the presbytery. And that is an English translation of the term, so we’re not gonna lose sleep over that one.
It’s talking about a group of elders. 1 Timothy 5, 17, he gives instruction about elders. Let the elders who rule well be considered worthy of double honor. He talks about the protection of the elders in two verses later in verse 19. Do not receive an accusation against an elder except on the basis of two or three witnesses. And so there is, it’s a dangerous position that they’ve occupied. They are targets of the enemy and sometimes targets even of critics of the church. And so he talks about the office of elder there.
Titus 1.5 talks about the appointment of elders, and we’re going to come back to this verse in a moment.
Just listen, Titus 1.5, for this reason, Paul tells Titus, I gave you marching orders. For this reason, I left you in Crete on this island that you should set in order what remains and appoint elders in every city as I directed you. And so Titus had a role. He had a mandate from Paul and from the Lord himself to go and appoint elders, plurality, in every church in every city.
James admonishes us, if we’re sick, call the elders and they are to come and pray over them. They are the spiritual leaders of the church and It’s not to say that you can’t have a deacon at your bedside if you’re sick, but primarily that is the work of the elder. And then there are exhortations throughout Scripture to elders and about elders, and we talked about some of this a couple of weeks ago. But 1 Peter 5, two examples, I exhort the elders among you.
Now he’s talking to the office, the leadership office of the church. Pardon me, I lost my place. As your fellow elder and witness of the suffering of Christ and partaker also of the glory to be revealed. And so he is admonishing the elders as a group collectively. 5.5, just a few verses later, you younger men likewise be subject to your elders. And so we all have a role. The elders are to lead and the saints are to support the elders and and ultimately submit to them.
We’ll talk more about that in, I think it’s the section five, whatever it is. So that’s the first term. The first term for the permanent office in the church is that of elder. The second term is that of overseer. And if you’re reading the King James, you’ll know that it’s called bishop. and that creates a problem and it stems from a longstanding mistranslation really. The word is episkopos and through a really clunky series of translations, that word episkopos ultimately was morphed into bishop, bishop. It’s a compound word and it’s a beautiful word Epi is over, and scopeo means to watch, scope. That’s where we get our word scope, to watch or to oversee. But historically, in the English translations, especially early on for the first three or four hundred years, it was translated as bishop. And what that came from, what we know as a transliteration. What does it sound like? Not what it means, what does it sound like? And to their ears, it sounded like bishop or bishop. There are about, I think, 20 or 24 different spellings throughout our English translation history.
And the verb there, episkopeo, is to oversee, to look over. It’s a very simple word. And one of the two occurrences refers to ecclesiastical duty. Listen carefully. Hebrews 12, 15 just gives a general admonition of overseeing. See to it, the writer of Hebrews says, see to it that no one comes short of the grace of God, that no root of bitterness springing up causes trouble, and by it many are defiled. And so he sees this thing in the church, and he probably is talking to the overseers here, the elders, but he just says, watch over your flock and make sure that there’s no little thing running through the church.
1 Peter 5.2, he’s talking to the elders here to the shepherds of the church. In fact, this is a beautiful section where all three terms for the leadership of the church are used. 1 Peter 5, 2, he admonishes the elders to shepherd the flock of God among you. And I’ve said it many times, you know, if some famous pastor came here and he’s an elder elsewhere, that doesn’t make him an elder here.
He is to shepherd his own flock, and that keeps our focus where it ought to be. Shepherd the flock of God among you, exercising oversight, playing the part of an overseer, watching over the saints, watching over their weaknesses, watching over their strengths, watching over their needs.
Exercising oversight, not under compulsion, but voluntarily, according to the will of God, And not for sordid gain, but with eagerness. And so we shouldn’t have to, you know, nourish people only with money in order to get the oversight that they are due. So the verb is used only two places. The feminine noun is used several times. And this just points to kind of an inspection, if you will, or the practical overseeing, watching over something. Luke 19 translates it as the time of your visitation.
Acts 1.20, it is written in the book of the Psalms, let his homestead be made desolate, speaking of Judas, and let no man dwell in it.
And his office, kind of an interesting translation there, his overseership, you might call it, 1 Timothy 3.1, it is a trustworthy statement if any man aspires to the office of overseer. Now, right away, you could begin to think that we are separating, creating multiple offices there because Titus calls it something different entirely, but it’s one of the many places where the terms are used interchangeably. He’s talking about one office of leadership in the church and Here he just refers to it as an overseer.
1 Peter 2.12, another translation.
Keep your behavior excellent among the Gentiles so that in the thing in which they slander you as evildoers, they may account of your good deeds as they observe them. Glorify God in the day of visitation. Now, this isn’t talking about the elders’ oversight of the flock. This is talking about Christ’s return. So that’s the way the word is used. And then there’s a masculine noun, episkopos, that is translated overseer or unfortunately bishop in many translations. And there are three of the four occurrences refer to the ecclesiastical office in the church. Bear with me.
The first one is Philippians 1.1. It’s an incredible passage. Paul and Timothy bond servants of Christ Jesus to the saints in Christ Jesus who are in Philippi, including the overseers and deacons. Now, you’ll hear me say later that if that’s referring to a third office, a bishop, then nowhere in that epistle does he address that. the elders of the church. It would be an absolutely absurd conclusion. No greeting at all to the elders?
The second time that it’s used, 1 Timothy 3.2, an overseer then must be above reproach. And here he talks about the character qualities, and he’s talking about the elders that he terms here overseers.
And then thirdly, The third use of it is in Titus 1.7. The overseer must be above reproach. Again, bringing character into the leadership of the church. And then the last time that it’s used is actually used of Christ.
1 Peter 2.25, you were continually straying like sheep, but now you have returned to the shepherd and the guardian, the overseer of your souls. Beautiful thought, and passage. And so the terms are used side by side there of the chief shepherd, our Lord Jesus, shepherd and guardian or overseer of your souls.
So not only is there the term elder and overseer, but there’s a third term, and that third term is really probably the most common of the three the church and that term is pastor or Shepherd and the word is poymen it typically refers simply to a shepherd even a shepherd of sheep and In the New Testament the the beautiful thing about this word is it’s used usually of Christ and I got to get rid of this Can you still hear me, okay All right, it just is too hot. If we could turn that down just a tad bit. I don’t know who’s here. Okay, we good? All right, so the third term is poimen, pastor or shepherd.
And the beautiful part, it’s usually used of Christ as our shepherd. The verb itself just means to tend. to care for, to rule, to nourish, to do everything that the sheep need of a literal shepherd, and it’s used 11 times in the New Testament. Five of those clearly point to Christ with reference to literal shepherding of his flock. Three of them plainly refer to the responsibility of church leadership, and only one time to false teachers. let me just catch up a little bit. Acts 20, 28, one of the key passages where he has called the elders to himself, and he says, be on guard for yourselves and for all the flock, among which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers to shepherd the church of God. And so now you have all three terms, elder, overseer, and shepherd, all melded into the same, and it’s the words are used interchangeably, to shepherd the church of God which he purchased with his own blood.
And the same exact thing happens in 1 Peter 5. All three terms are there, present, and interchangeable. Peter just says, shepherd the flock of God among you, exercising oversight, not under compulsion, but voluntarily according to the will of God. And so…
Those are clearly referring to the office of elder in the church that are overseeing Christ’s flock. And then the noun appointment is translated simply as shepherd, and it’s used 18 times in the New Testament. Eight of those clearly refer to Jesus as the great shepherd. Five of them allude to Christ. They kind of allude to Christ as such. Four of them referring to literal shepherds. I’m talking shepherds with sheep, literal sheep. Only one of those 18 refers to leaders in the church, and it’s translated only there as pastor. And that’s why I’m not dogged about the use of that term. I mean, I understand it. People use it of me all the time, and I’m not offended by it. Here’s how the passage reads.
He gave some as apostles, some as prophets, some as evangelists, and some as pastors or shepherds and teachers. That’s the use of the term. And so we can back away from those three terms and begin to draw some conclusion from The biblical data. The three terms, elder, pastor or shepherd, and overseer, all refer to the same leadership office in the New Testament church. All three Greek words are used with reference to the primary, permanent office of spiritual leadership in the church. They’re interchangeable. And that’s proven true. over and over in the scriptures.
In 1 Timothy 3, the qualification of an overseer there in 1 Timothy 3 is almost identical to the qualities of an elder in Titus. And so either we’re talking about two competing offices and you have You have churches that employ this model where they’ve got elders in the local churches, but they’ve got a bishop elsewhere that oversees a number of churches. It just is plainly evident that the list in Timothy and the list in Titus are talking about the same office, even though it’s referred to with different terms. The fact that in Titus 1, 5 through 7…
The terms elder and overseer are used interchangeably. Just listen to Titus chapter 1, verse 5, where Paul says, for this reason I left you Titus in Crete that you might set in order what remains and appoint elders in every city just as I directed you. Namely, If any man be above reproach, the husband of one wife, having children who believe, not accused of dissipation or rebellion, for the overseer must be above reproach. So there he uses elders and overseers, and it’s clearly interchangeable there. In Acts 20, I mentioned this a moment ago, that this same situation occurs. But here in Acts 20, all three terms are used in conjunction with one another, interchangeably.
Verse 17 tells us that from Miletus, Paul sent to Ephesus and called to him the elders of the church. That’s who he’s meeting with. And then in verse 28, which verse we read just a moment ago, he says, Be on guard for yourselves and for all the flock, among which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers to shepherd the the church of God.
All three terms in that same section, and so there are not multiple offices. One office, whether it’s called elder, overseer, or shepherd, or pastor. And the same exact thing we saw a moment ago, and I told you I’d come back to this passage. 1 Peter 5, 1 and 2, The terms elder, shepherd, and overseer are all used interchangeably in that passage as well. 1 Peter 5, therefore, I exhort the elders among you as your fellow elder and witness of the sufferings of Christ and partaker of the glory that is to be revealed. Shepherd, that’s the admonition, that’s the command to the elders to shepherd the flock of God among you. exercising oversight. This talks about the means of shepherding, looking out over your flock, not under compulsion, but voluntarily.
And then Philippians, the interesting thing here, if there are three offices, which would be bishops, elders, and deacons, why would Paul only address the first and the third overseers and deacons and not mention elders at all. That’s the point that I made a moment ago.
When he refers to overseers there in Philippians 1.1, he’s clearly referring to the office of eldership. And so there are conclusions that we can begin to draw.
Tyndale made this comment. I’m talking about William Tyndale, one of the original translators of the New Testament from Greek into English. And even though he refers to it as bishop, that office of overseer, he lands on a good place. Listen to this. And believe me, his English is, you know, if there are any grammarians here, bear with him. He’s trying.
Bishops and elders is all one. and an officer chosen to govern the congregation in doctrine and living. In other words, he says, overseers and elders are one and the same. They are the office of leadership in the church. John Murray, faithful, godly Presbyterian pastor said, elders and shepherds of the flock are to shepherd the church of God and It is the same shepherd that appears in Ephesians 4.11, which is translated there as pastor, as I pointed out. Since Paul penned the latter, it would be necessary for us to infer that he has in view the same function which he enjoined upon the elders from Ephesus. In other words, one office referred to in different ways.
And so the conclusion is that the pastors, the shepherds, of Ephesians 4.11, are those designated in Acts 20, 17, and 28 as elders and bishops. In a word, Murray says, the evidence would require the conclusion that pastors are elders of the church of God. They are the ones that are appointed to oversee Christ’s church. In a Dear brother in Christ in glory, MacArthur said it so simply.
Bishops and pastors are not distinct from elders. The terms are simply different ways of identifying the same people. All three terms refer to the same office. So the term elder emphasizes who the man is. Bishop speaks of what he does. And pastor deals with how he feels in the pastoral role of caring and feeding his flock. Now, I’ll take time for questions in one second, but I just want to give you, there’s one practical application. That’s what we try to do at the end of each of these sections. What do we do with all this data? And I think it’s simple.
The church should endeavor to use one title for all. and I’ll give you my preference here in a moment. For all elders in the church, they should use the same title. Either call them elder or overseer or shepherd or pastor. And here’s where this works itself out in the congregation.
If we’re at King Soopers and I walk in and you’re talking with a friend and you go to introduce me, I don’t expect you, in fact, I would think it quite odd if you referred to, this is Elder Frasco. Because then you’re pointing to my age and yeah, it is gonna be uncomfortable. I think that is a step too far with regard to the use, I don’t think it’s intended as an office title. Nor, I mean, if you introduce me as the Overseer Frasco, they might wonder if I’m a little creepy. following you around, King Soopers.
Likewise with shepherd. I mean, within 15 miles of this church, there are flocks of sheep being tended by shepherds. And so I don’t expect you to use that term as well, nor am I offended. There’s only one thing that I will ask you, and I’ve been called a lot of things, but I don’t like to be called reverend. And unfortunately, it’s funerals or sometimes, depending on whose service you’re doing, a wedding. They’ll put you in the program as the very, you know, the Reverend Frasco will be doing this. I can’t stand that. I am not to be revered or applauded that we talked about that.
And so I understand the use of the term pastor. I only have one caveat here. If we have a plurality in the church, they are all pastors. They are all shepherding the flock. They are all overseeing God’s people. And we should seek to use one term for all because as soon as you begin to do this, senior pastor, you’ve already begun to… Remember that jello where you would pour something in and create three layers? Remember? Yeah. Yeah. That’s essentially what you have in the church as soon as you start to call, well, he’s the senior pastor. Well, he’s the pastor over youth.
Or you’ve begun to create an unbiblical distinction among the elders that are all supposed to be on the same level in a plurality. So I’m not against the term pastor, even though it’s only translated once. If you’re talking to a fellow believer, I’m I’m fine with you introducing me.
This is one of the shepherds of our flock. This is one of the elders of our church. But I don’t need a title. I don’t mind if you introduce me as Ron and let them find out in time how I’m functioning. But the title pastor is common and understandable in our community. We just want to use that term of all the elders in our midst.
So, questions, concerns, comments? Oh, come on, I didn’t do that. Good of a job. Certainly there’s some controversy woven in. Dave, yeah. Yeah, beautiful. And that kind of comes out in MacArthur’s definition that I read at last, but Elder describes who he is, and yeah. Dylan.
Well, number one, I think that there is a biblical model for church government. And I think to go away from that, to go to pastor deacons or a CEO or I, what are some of the other titles you’ve heard of churches? Sorry? Executive director. Yeah. In fact, we were at a deal. I was at a deal not long ago. I won’t point where, but We were at a deal where they asked for an executive pastor. I don’t know what that is. I don’t know what it is to be called the primary preaching pastor. I don’t know what that is. There’s a pastor and he’s shepherding his flock.
That’s ideal. Oh, very common. When really they’re all functioning the same and that’s part of we’re going to have to work our way out of this. We’re out of shape. And when we do have a plurality, it’s going to take some time, but we’re going to have to get to a point where we do consider all of these brothers as our shepherds in our midst, elders. All of them are overseeing. All of them can be considered pastors of the church. Yeah, we’re out of sync.
And so You probably had an angle when you asked that question. Do you want to explain? And my own is just the incorporation of worldly terms into the church. I mean, I remember, well, I’ll shorten this. To share a title, shepherd, with the Lord Jesus Christ, I mean, there’s no way that I would ever push myself into that consideration. But scripture does. And he has called us his under shepherds here in the flock in a role that he fulfills perfectly. All we have to do is to emulate and seek to do. And so I think terminology is crucial. And we get, I think churches get off and into the ditch very easily with some of these other titles.
I don’t like associate pastor. I don’t like youth pastor. Not personally. They’re fine people. I don’t like the terminologies. It begins to separate. If they’re even, how can you even, you know, if some guy’s a youth pastor and he hasn’t even gotten out of college yet, he’s not an elder in the church, why call him, now we’ve just stripped away any significance of that title, and I think it’s a dangerous thing for the church. Yes, sir. And we do use that, and we use that only to point to the fact that there are going to be some in the midst, the exegete, you know, if there’s one, the one that’s doing the primary role of preaching, it does identify that, but you can go too far with that for sure. Well, I’ve said it many times. If I knew that we had three solid exegetes that were capable and desirous, I would be fine with breaking the preaching up into thirds if you had three, or some you know, 20% here and 20% there and 60% over here.
I think that depends on the church. It depends on what God has given. And they should all be at peace and functioning according to their giftedness. It’s a great question. And I think, you know, what a great gift if God gives multiple men the ability to teach and preach. Yes, ma’am. That too is up to the church. Yeah. We’ll talk about remuneration here. I think it’s somewhere in there. We talk about remuneration, paying one as opposed to the other. Anyone? Yes. Yes.
I guess the first thing we’d have to, what Renee is asking is what about calling somebody a youth pastor if he’s doing youth or Spanish-speaking ministry. My thing goes back to what is the need, what’s the fallout from that? As long as it doesn’t begin to distinguish or create layers, this is pastor, Jones, he’s in charge of our Spanish ministry. That just seems to have a much better way of communicating the totality of that. This is Sam, and he’s in charge of our youth ministry. Yeah, rather than creating distinctions, unbiblical distinctions. And we, you know, we do a lot of that from up here, just kind of communicating, look, this is the kind of direction we want to go. but it’s constant. You have to constantly watch over it. Yes, Sandy? Yeah.
My only thing is I don’t like to water down the term pastor, shepherd. If the guy is not an elder, I think that term ought to be, you can call him a youth worker, you can call him a, you know, that guy, but you just don’t call him pastor. I’m against calling anybody pastor who is not functioning as an elder or called. Any last ones?
All right, so next time we’ll pick up with the fact of, you know, how do they get from point A to point B? How do we, and this is crucial for the church, our church, how do we begin to go about recognizing elders in our midst, and we will tackle that next time. Ryan, would you mind closing us in prayer?
Messages: 1